Crime and Substance Abuse
Source: *Substance Use & Misuse*
Date of Publication: *2002*
Author(s): *Clifford A. Butzin, Christine A. Saum, Frank R. Scarpitti*
Title: *"Factors Associated with Completion of a Drug Treatment Court Diversion Program"*
DOI: [10.1081/JA-120014424](https://doi.org/10.1081/JA-120014424)
Subject Matter: *Substance Use, Criminal Justice, Drug Courts*
- General Observations:
- Study examined drug treatment court success rates among first-time offenders.
- Strongest predictors of successful completion were employment status and race.
2. Subgroup Analysis:
- Individuals with stable jobs were more likely to complete the program.
- Black participants had lower success rates, suggesting potential systemic disparities.
3. Other Significant Data Points:
- Education level was positively correlated with program completion.
- Frequency of drug use before enrollment affected treatment outcomes.
- Primary Observations:
- Social stability factors (employment, education) were key to treatment success.
- Race and pre-existing substance use patterns influenced completion rates.
2. Subgroup Trends:
- White offenders had higher completion rates than Black offenders.
- Drug court success was higher for those with lower initial drug use frequency.
3. Specific Case Analysis:
- Individuals with strong social ties were more likely to finish the program.
- Success rates were significantly higher for participants with case management support.
- Strengths of the Study:
- First empirical study on drug court program success factors.
- Uses longitudinal data for post-treatment analysis.
2. Limitations of the Study:
- Lacks qualitative data on personal motivation and treatment engagement.
- Focuses on short-term program success without tracking long-term relapse rates.
3. Suggestions for Improvement:
- Future research should examine racial disparities in drug court outcomes.
- Study how community resources impact long-term recovery.
- Provides insight into what factors contribute to drug court program success.
- Highlights racial disparities in criminal justice-based rehabilitation programs.
- Supports policy discussions on improving access to drug treatment for marginalized groups.
- Investigate the role of mental health in drug court success rates.
2. Assess long-term relapse prevention strategies post-treatment.
3. Explore alternative diversion programs beyond traditional drug courts.
Source: *Substance Use & Misuse*
Date of Publication: *2003*
Author(s): *Timothy P. Johnson, Phillip J. Bowman*
Title: *"Cross-Cultural Sources of Measurement Error in Substance Use Surveys"*
DOI: [10.1081/JA-120023394](https://doi.org/10.1081/JA-120023394)
Subject Matter: *Survey Methodology, Racial Disparities, Substance Use Research*
- General Observations:
- Study examined how racial and cultural factors influence self-reported substance use data.
- Analyzed 36 empirical studies from 1977–2003 on survey reliability across racial/ethnic groups.
2. Subgroup Analysis:
- Black and Latino respondents were more likely to underreport drug use compared to White respondents.
- Cultural stigma and distrust in research institutions affected self-report accuracy.
3. Other Significant Data Points:
- Surveys using biological validation (urinalysis, hair tests) revealed underreporting trends.
- Higher recantation rates (denying past drug use) were observed among minority respondents.
- Primary Observations:
- Racial/ethnic disparities in substance use reporting bias survey-based research.
- Social desirability and cultural norms impact data reliability.
2. Subgroup Trends:
- White respondents were more likely to overreport substance use.
- Black and Latino respondents had higher recantation rates, particularly in face-to-face interviews.
3. Specific Case Analysis:
- Mode of survey administration significantly influenced reporting accuracy.
- Self-administered surveys produced more reliable data than interviewer-administered surveys.
- Strengths of the Study:
- Comprehensive review of 36 studies on measurement error in substance use reporting.
- Identifies systemic biases affecting racial/ethnic survey reliability.
2. Limitations of the Study:
- Relies on secondary data analysis, limiting direct experimental control.
- Does not explore how measurement error impacts policy decisions.
3. Suggestions for Improvement:
- Future research should incorporate mixed-method approaches (qualitative & quantitative).
- Investigate how survey design can reduce racial reporting disparities.
- Supports research on racial disparities in self-reported health behaviors.
- Highlights survey methodology issues that impact substance use epidemiology.
- Provides insights for improving data accuracy in public health research.
- Investigate how survey design impacts racial disparities in self-reported health data.
2. Study alternative data collection methods (biometric validation, passive data tracking).
3. Explore the role of social stigma in self-reported health behaviors.
Source: *Substance Use & Misuse*
Date of Publication: *2002*
Author(s): *Clifford A. Butzin, Christine A. Saum, Frank R. Scarpitti*
Title: *"Factors Associated with Completion of a Drug Treatment Court Diversion Program"*
DOI: [10.1081/JA-120014424](https://doi.org/10.1081/JA-120014424)
Subject Matter: *Substance Use, Criminal Justice, Drug Courts*
- General Observations:
- Study examined drug treatment court success rates among first-time offenders.
- Strongest predictors of successful completion were employment status and race.
2. Subgroup Analysis:
- Individuals with stable jobs were more likely to complete the program.
- Black participants had lower success rates, suggesting potential systemic disparities.
3. Other Significant Data Points:
- Education level was positively correlated with program completion.
- Frequency of drug use before enrollment affected treatment outcomes.
- Primary Observations:
- Social stability factors (employment, education) were key to treatment success.
- Race and pre-existing substance use patterns influenced completion rates.
2. Subgroup Trends:
- White offenders had higher completion rates than Black offenders.
- Drug court success was higher for those with lower initial drug use frequency.
3. Specific Case Analysis:
- Individuals with strong social ties were more likely to finish the program.
- Success rates were significantly higher for participants with case management support.
- Strengths of the Study:
- First empirical study on drug court program success factors.
- Uses longitudinal data for post-treatment analysis.
2. Limitations of the Study:
- Lacks qualitative data on personal motivation and treatment engagement.
- Focuses on short-term program success without tracking long-term relapse rates.
3. Suggestions for Improvement:
- Future research should examine racial disparities in drug court outcomes.
- Study how community resources impact long-term recovery.
- Provides insight into what factors contribute to drug court program success.
- Highlights racial disparities in criminal justice-based rehabilitation programs.
- Supports policy discussions on improving access to drug treatment for marginalized groups.
- Investigate the role of mental health in drug court success rates.
2. Assess long-term relapse prevention strategies post-treatment.
3. Explore alternative diversion programs beyond traditional drug courts.
