0 Votes

Studies: Crime and Substance Abuse

Version 14.1 by Ryan C on 2025/06/23 01:44

Crime and Substance Abuse

Study: Factors Associated with Completion of a Drug Treatment Court Diversion Program

Source: *Substance Use & Misuse*
Date of Publication: *2002*
Author(s): *Clifford A. Butzin, Christine A. Saum, Frank R. Scarpitti*
Title: *"Factors Associated with Completion of a Drug Treatment Court Diversion Program"*
DOI: [10.1081/JA-120014424](https://doi.org/10.1081/JA-120014424)
Subject Matter: *Substance Use, Criminal Justice, Drug Courts*

๐Ÿ“Š Key Statistics
  1. General Observations:
       - Study examined drug treatment court success rates among first-time offenders.
       - Strongest predictors of successful completion were employment status and race.

2. Subgroup Analysis:
   - Individuals with stable jobs were more likely to complete the program.
   - Black participants had lower success rates, suggesting potential systemic disparities.

3. Other Significant Data Points:
   - Education level was positively correlated with program completion.
   - Frequency of drug use before enrollment affected treatment outcomes.

๐Ÿ”ฌ Findings
  1. Primary Observations:
       - Social stability factors (employment, education) were key to treatment success.
       - Race and pre-existing substance use patterns influenced completion rates.

2. Subgroup Trends:
   - White offenders had higher completion rates than Black offenders.
   - Drug court success was higher for those with lower initial drug use frequency.

3. Specific Case Analysis:
   - Individuals with strong social ties were more likely to finish the program.
   - Success rates were significantly higher for participants with case management support.

๐Ÿ“ Critique & Observations
  1. Strengths of the Study:
       - First empirical study on drug court program success factors.
       - Uses longitudinal data for post-treatment analysis.

2. Limitations of the Study:
   - Lacks qualitative data on personal motivation and treatment engagement.
   - Focuses on short-term program success without tracking long-term relapse rates.

3. Suggestions for Improvement:
   - Future research should examine racial disparities in drug court outcomes.
   - Study how community resources impact long-term recovery.

๐Ÿ“Œ Relevance to Subproject

- Provides insight into what factors contribute to drug court program success.
- Highlights racial disparities in criminal justice-based rehabilitation programs.
- Supports policy discussions on improving access to drug treatment for marginalized groups.

๐Ÿ” Suggestions for Further Exploration
  1. Investigate the role of mental health in drug court success rates.
    2. Assess long-term relapse prevention strategies post-treatment.
    3. Explore alternative diversion programs beyond traditional drug courts.
Study: Cross-Cultural Sources of Measurement Error in Substance Use Surveys

Source: *Substance Use & Misuse*
Date of Publication: *2003*
Author(s): *Timothy P. Johnson, Phillip J. Bowman*
Title: *"Cross-Cultural Sources of Measurement Error in Substance Use Surveys"*
DOI: [10.1081/JA-120023394](https://doi.org/10.1081/JA-120023394)
Subject Matter: *Survey Methodology, Racial Disparities, Substance Use Research*

๐Ÿ“Š Key Statistics
  1. General Observations:
       - Study examined how racial and cultural factors influence self-reported substance use data.
       - Analyzed 36 empirical studies from 1977โ€“2003 on survey reliability across racial/ethnic groups.

2. Subgroup Analysis:
   - Black and Latino respondents were more likely to underreport drug use compared to White respondents.
   - Cultural stigma and distrust in research institutions affected self-report accuracy.

3. Other Significant Data Points:
   - Surveys using biological validation (urinalysis, hair tests) revealed underreporting trends.
   - Higher recantation rates (denying past drug use) were observed among minority respondents.

๐Ÿ”ฌ Findings
  1. Primary Observations:
       - Racial/ethnic disparities in substance use reporting bias survey-based research.
       - Social desirability and cultural norms impact data reliability.

2. Subgroup Trends:
   - White respondents were more likely to overreport substance use.
   - Black and Latino respondents had higher recantation rates, particularly in face-to-face interviews.

3. Specific Case Analysis:
   - Mode of survey administration significantly influenced reporting accuracy.
   - Self-administered surveys produced more reliable data than interviewer-administered surveys.

๐Ÿ“ Critique & Observations
  1. Strengths of the Study:
       - Comprehensive review of 36 studies on measurement error in substance use reporting.
       - Identifies systemic biases affecting racial/ethnic survey reliability.

2. Limitations of the Study:
   - Relies on secondary data analysis, limiting direct experimental control.
   - Does not explore how measurement error impacts policy decisions.

3. Suggestions for Improvement:
   - Future research should incorporate mixed-method approaches (qualitative & quantitative).
   - Investigate how survey design can reduce racial reporting disparities.

๐Ÿ“Œ Relevance to Subproject

- Supports research on racial disparities in self-reported health behaviors.
- Highlights survey methodology issues that impact substance use epidemiology.
- Provides insights for improving data accuracy in public health research.

๐Ÿ” Suggestions for Further Exploration
  1. Investigate how survey design impacts racial disparities in self-reported health data.
    2. Study alternative data collection methods (biometric validation, passive data tracking).
    3. Explore the role of social stigma in self-reported health behaviors.
Study: Racial Differences in Marijuana Usersโ€™ Risk of Arrest in the United States

Source: *Drug and Alcohol Dependence*  
Date of Publication: *2006*  
Author(s): *Rajeev Ramchand, Rosalie Liccardo Pacula, Martin Y. Iguchi*  
Title: *"Racial Differences in Marijuana Usersโ€™ Risk of Arrest in the United States"*  
DOI: [10.1016/j.drugalcdep.2006.02.010](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.drugalcdep.2006.02.010)  
Subject Matter: *Marijuana Use, Policing, Racial Disparities, Drug Markets*

๐Ÿ“Š Key Statistics
  1. General Observations:
       - African Americans are 2.5ร— more likely to be arrested for marijuana possession than Whites.
       - Arrest disparity persists despite similar usage rates between groups.

2. Subgroup Analysis:
   - African Americans were:
     - Twice as likely to buy outdoors (0.31 vs. 0.14)
     - Three times as likely to buy from a stranger (0.30 vs. 0.09)
     - More likely to buy away from home (0.61 vs. 0.48)

3. Other Significant Data Points:
   - Over 39% of all U.S. drug arrests in 2002 were for marijuana possession.
   - Nearly 80% of the increase in drug arrests from 1990โ€“2002 was due to marijuana alone.

๐Ÿ”ฌ Findings
  1. Primary Observations:
       - Differences in purchasing behavior partially explain racial arrest disparities.
       - Riskier purchasing settings (outdoors, strangers, away from home) increase arrest probability.

2. Subgroup Trends:
   - African Americansโ€™ higher arrest rates are linked more to behavioral exposure than usage frequency.
   - Purchasing from strangers and in public correlates with law enforcement encounters.

3. Specific Case Analysis:
   - Results based on 2002 National Survey on Drug Use and Health (NSDUH).
   - Multivariate regression models confirm race remains a significant predictor even after controlling for demographics and behaviors.

๐Ÿ“ Critique & Observations
  1. Strengths of the Study:
       - Uses nationally representative survey data and robust statistical modeling.
       - Separates usage rates from behavior-related arrest risks.

2. Limitations of the Study:
   - Focused specifically on marijuana, may not generalize to other drugs.
   - Does not directly test law enforcement bias, only behavioral correlates of arrest risk.

3. Suggestions for Improvement:
   - Include law enforcement data on arrest locations and procedures.
   - Extend model to longitudinal outcomes (repeat arrest, conviction).

๐Ÿ“Œ Relevance to Subproject

- Supports the argument that behavioral patternsโ€”not usage ratesโ€”drive racial arrest disparities.
- Highlights systemic vulnerability among Black marijuana users due to social context of purchases.
- Reinforces critique of โ€œrace-neutralโ€ enforcement in drug policy discussions.

๐Ÿ” Suggestions for Further Exploration
  1. Study how police patrol patterns correlate with outdoor purchasing risk.  
    2. Investigate racial profiling in drug arrests beyond behavioral correlates.  
    3. Compare marijuana purchase risks in urban vs. suburban contexts.

XWiki AI Chat