... |
... |
@@ -1203,77 +1203,329 @@ |
1203 |
1203 |
|
1204 |
1204 |
{{html}}<hr style="border: 3px solid red;">{{/html}} |
1205 |
1205 |
|
1206 |
|
-{{expand title="Study: Genetic Analysis of African Populations: Human Evolution and Complex Disease" expanded="false"}} |
1207 |
|
-**Source:** *Nature Reviews Genetics* |
|
1206 |
+ |
|
1207 |
+ |
|
1208 |
+{{expand title="Study: Racial Bias in Pain Assessment and Treatment Recommendations" expanded="false"}} |
|
1209 |
+**Source:** *Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (PNAS)* |
|
1210 |
+**Date of Publication:** *2016* |
|
1211 |
+**Author(s):** *Kelly M. Hoffman, Sophie Trawalter, Jordan R. Axta, M. Norman Oliver* |
|
1212 |
+**Title:** *"Racial Bias in Pain Assessment and Treatment Recommendations, and False Beliefs About Biological Differences Between Blacks and Whites"* |
|
1213 |
+**DOI:** [10.1073/pnas.1516047113](https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1516047113) |
|
1214 |
+**Subject Matter:** *Health Disparities, Racial Bias, Medical Treatment* |
|
1215 |
+ |
|
1216 |
+--- |
|
1217 |
+ |
|
1218 |
+## **Key Statistics** |
|
1219 |
+1. **General Observations:** |
|
1220 |
+ - Study analyzed **racial disparities in pain perception and treatment recommendations**. |
|
1221 |
+ - Found that **white laypeople and medical students endorsed false beliefs about biological differences** between Black and white individuals. |
|
1222 |
+ |
|
1223 |
+2. **Subgroup Analysis:** |
|
1224 |
+ - **50% of medical students surveyed endorsed at least one false belief about biological differences**. |
|
1225 |
+ - Participants who held these false beliefs were **more likely to underestimate Black patients’ pain levels**. |
|
1226 |
+ |
|
1227 |
+3. **Other Significant Data Points:** |
|
1228 |
+ - **Black patients were less likely to receive appropriate pain treatment** compared to white patients. |
|
1229 |
+ - The study confirmed that **historical misconceptions about racial differences still persist in modern medicine**. |
|
1230 |
+ |
|
1231 |
+--- |
|
1232 |
+ |
|
1233 |
+## **Findings** |
|
1234 |
+1. **Primary Observations:** |
|
1235 |
+ - False beliefs about biological racial differences **correlate with racial disparities in pain treatment**. |
|
1236 |
+ - Medical students and residents who endorsed these beliefs **showed greater racial bias in treatment recommendations**. |
|
1237 |
+ |
|
1238 |
+2. **Subgroup Trends:** |
|
1239 |
+ - Physicians who **did not endorse these beliefs** showed **no racial bias** in treatment recommendations. |
|
1240 |
+ - Bias was **strongest among first-year medical students** and decreased slightly in later years of training. |
|
1241 |
+ |
|
1242 |
+3. **Specific Case Analysis:** |
|
1243 |
+ - Study participants **underestimated Black patients' pain and recommended less effective pain treatments**. |
|
1244 |
+ - The study suggests that **racial disparities in medical care stem, in part, from these enduring false beliefs**. |
|
1245 |
+ |
|
1246 |
+--- |
|
1247 |
+ |
|
1248 |
+## **Critique and Observations** |
|
1249 |
+1. **Strengths of the Study:** |
|
1250 |
+ - **First empirical study to connect false racial beliefs with medical decision-making**. |
|
1251 |
+ - Utilizes a **large sample of medical students and residents** from diverse institutions. |
|
1252 |
+ |
|
1253 |
+2. **Limitations of the Study:** |
|
1254 |
+ - The study focuses on **Black vs. white disparities**, leaving other racial/ethnic groups unexplored. |
|
1255 |
+ - Participants' responses were based on **hypothetical medical cases, not real-world treatment decisions**. |
|
1256 |
+ |
|
1257 |
+3. **Suggestions for Improvement:** |
|
1258 |
+ - Future research should examine **how these biases manifest in real clinical settings**. |
|
1259 |
+ - Investigate **whether medical training can correct these biases over time**. |
|
1260 |
+ |
|
1261 |
+--- |
|
1262 |
+ |
|
1263 |
+## **Relevance to Subproject** |
|
1264 |
+- Highlights **racial disparities in healthcare**, specifically in pain assessment and treatment. |
|
1265 |
+- Supports **research on implicit bias and its impact on medical outcomes**. |
|
1266 |
+- Provides evidence for **the need to address racial bias in medical education**. |
|
1267 |
+ |
|
1268 |
+--- |
|
1269 |
+ |
|
1270 |
+## **Suggestions for Further Exploration** |
|
1271 |
+1. Investigate **interventions to reduce racial bias in medical decision-making**. |
|
1272 |
+2. Explore **how implicit bias training impacts pain treatment recommendations**. |
|
1273 |
+3. Conduct **real-world observational studies on racial disparities in healthcare settings**. |
|
1274 |
+ |
|
1275 |
+--- |
|
1276 |
+ |
|
1277 |
+## **Summary of Research Study** |
|
1278 |
+This study examines **racial bias in pain perception and treatment** among **white laypeople and medical professionals**, demonstrating that **false beliefs about biological differences contribute to disparities in pain management**. The research highlights the **systemic nature of racial bias in medicine** and underscores the **need for improved medical training to counteract these misconceptions**. |
|
1279 |
+ |
|
1280 |
+This summary provides an accessible, at-a-glance overview of the study’s contributions. Please refer to the full paper for in-depth analysis. |
|
1281 |
+ |
|
1282 |
+--- |
|
1283 |
+ |
|
1284 |
+## **📄 Download Full Study** |
|
1285 |
+[[Download Full Study>>attach:10.1073_pnas.1516047113.pdf]] |
|
1286 |
+ |
|
1287 |
+{{/expand}} |
|
1288 |
+ |
|
1289 |
+{{html}}<hr style="border: 3px solid red;">{{/html}} |
|
1290 |
+ |
|
1291 |
+ |
|
1292 |
+{{expand title="Study: Rising Morbidity and Mortality in Midlife Among White Non-Hispanic Americans" expanded="false"}} |
|
1293 |
+**Source:** *Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (PNAS)* |
|
1294 |
+**Date of Publication:** *2015* |
|
1295 |
+**Author(s):** *Anne Case, Angus Deaton* |
|
1296 |
+**Title:** *"Rising Morbidity and Mortality in Midlife Among White Non-Hispanic Americans in the 21st Century"* |
|
1297 |
+**DOI:** [10.1073/pnas.1518393112](https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1518393112) |
|
1298 |
+**Subject Matter:** *Public Health, Mortality, Socioeconomic Factors* |
|
1299 |
+ |
|
1300 |
+--- |
|
1301 |
+ |
|
1302 |
+## **Key Statistics** |
|
1303 |
+1. **General Observations:** |
|
1304 |
+ - Mortality rates among **middle-aged white non-Hispanic Americans (ages 45–54)** increased from 1999 to 2013. |
|
1305 |
+ - This reversal in mortality trends is unique to the U.S.; **no other wealthy country experienced a similar rise**. |
|
1306 |
+ |
|
1307 |
+2. **Subgroup Analysis:** |
|
1308 |
+ - The increase was **most pronounced among those with a high school education or less**. |
|
1309 |
+ - Hispanic and Black non-Hispanic mortality continued to decline over the same period. |
|
1310 |
+ |
|
1311 |
+3. **Other Significant Data Points:** |
|
1312 |
+ - Rising mortality was driven primarily by **suicide, drug and alcohol poisoning, and chronic liver disease**. |
|
1313 |
+ - Midlife morbidity increased as well, with more reports of **poor health, pain, and mental distress**. |
|
1314 |
+ |
|
1315 |
+--- |
|
1316 |
+ |
|
1317 |
+## **Findings** |
|
1318 |
+1. **Primary Observations:** |
|
1319 |
+ - The rise in mortality is attributed to **substance abuse, economic distress, and deteriorating mental health**. |
|
1320 |
+ - The increase in **suicides and opioid overdoses parallels broader socioeconomic decline**. |
|
1321 |
+ |
|
1322 |
+2. **Subgroup Trends:** |
|
1323 |
+ - The **largest mortality increases** occurred among **whites without a college degree**. |
|
1324 |
+ - Chronic pain, functional limitations, and self-reported mental distress **rose significantly in affected groups**. |
|
1325 |
+ |
|
1326 |
+3. **Specific Case Analysis:** |
|
1327 |
+ - **Educational attainment was a major predictor of mortality trends**, with better-educated individuals experiencing lower mortality rates. |
|
1328 |
+ - Mortality among **white Americans with a college degree continued to decline**, resembling trends in other wealthy nations. |
|
1329 |
+ |
|
1330 |
+--- |
|
1331 |
+ |
|
1332 |
+## **Critique and Observations** |
|
1333 |
+1. **Strengths of the Study:** |
|
1334 |
+ - **First major study to highlight rising midlife mortality among U.S. whites**. |
|
1335 |
+ - Uses **CDC and Census mortality data spanning over a decade**. |
|
1336 |
+ |
|
1337 |
+2. **Limitations of the Study:** |
|
1338 |
+ - Does not establish **causality** between economic decline and increased mortality. |
|
1339 |
+ - Lacks **granular data on opioid prescribing patterns and regional differences**. |
|
1340 |
+ |
|
1341 |
+3. **Suggestions for Improvement:** |
|
1342 |
+ - Future studies should explore **how economic shifts, healthcare access, and mental health treatment contribute to these trends**. |
|
1343 |
+ - Further research on **racial and socioeconomic disparities in mortality trends** is needed. |
|
1344 |
+ |
|
1345 |
+--- |
|
1346 |
+ |
|
1347 |
+## **Relevance to Subproject** |
|
1348 |
+- Highlights **socioeconomic and racial disparities** in health outcomes. |
|
1349 |
+- Supports research on **substance abuse and mental health crises in the U.S.**. |
|
1350 |
+- Provides evidence for **the role of economic instability in public health trends**. |
|
1351 |
+ |
|
1352 |
+--- |
|
1353 |
+ |
|
1354 |
+## **Suggestions for Further Exploration** |
|
1355 |
+1. Investigate **regional differences in rising midlife mortality**. |
|
1356 |
+2. Examine the **impact of the opioid crisis on long-term health trends**. |
|
1357 |
+3. Study **policy interventions aimed at reversing rising mortality rates**. |
|
1358 |
+ |
|
1359 |
+--- |
|
1360 |
+ |
|
1361 |
+## **Summary of Research Study** |
|
1362 |
+This study documents a **reversal in mortality trends among middle-aged white non-Hispanic Americans**, showing an increase in **suicide, drug overdoses, and alcohol-related deaths** from 1999 to 2013. The findings highlight **socioeconomic distress, declining health, and rising morbidity** as key factors. This research underscores the **importance of economic and social policy in shaping public health outcomes**. |
|
1363 |
+ |
|
1364 |
+This summary provides an accessible, at-a-glance overview of the study’s contributions. Please refer to the full paper for in-depth analysis. |
|
1365 |
+ |
|
1366 |
+--- |
|
1367 |
+ |
|
1368 |
+## **📄 Download Full Study** |
|
1369 |
+[[Download Full Study>>attach:10.1073_pnas.1518393112.pdf]] |
|
1370 |
+ |
|
1371 |
+{{/expand}} |
|
1372 |
+ |
|
1373 |
+{{html}}<hr style="border: 3px solid red;">{{/html}} |
|
1374 |
+ |
|
1375 |
+{{expand title="Study: How Do People Without Migration Background Experience and Impact Today’s Superdiverse Cities?" expanded="false"}} |
|
1376 |
+**Source:** *Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies* |
|
1377 |
+**Date of Publication:** *2023* |
|
1378 |
+**Author(s):** *Maurice Crul, Frans Lelie, Elif Keskiner, Laure Michon, Ismintha Waldring* |
|
1379 |
+**Title:** *"How Do People Without Migration Background Experience and Impact Today’s Superdiverse Cities?"* |
|
1380 |
+**DOI:** [10.1080/1369183X.2023.2182548](https://doi.org/10.1080/1369183X.2023.2182548) |
|
1381 |
+**Subject Matter:** *Urban Sociology, Migration Studies, Integration* |
|
1382 |
+ |
|
1383 |
+--- |
|
1384 |
+ |
|
1385 |
+## **Key Statistics** |
|
1386 |
+1. **General Observations:** |
|
1387 |
+ - Study examines the role of **people without migration background** in majority-minority cities. |
|
1388 |
+ - Analyzes **over 3,000 survey responses and 150 in-depth interviews** from six North-Western European cities. |
|
1389 |
+ |
|
1390 |
+2. **Subgroup Analysis:** |
|
1391 |
+ - Explores differences in **integration, social interactions, and perceptions of diversity**. |
|
1392 |
+ - Studies how **class, education, and neighborhood composition** affect adaptation to urban diversity. |
|
1393 |
+ |
|
1394 |
+3. **Other Significant Data Points:** |
|
1395 |
+ - The study introduces the **Becoming a Minority (BaM) project**, a large-scale investigation of urban demographic shifts. |
|
1396 |
+ - **People without migration background perceive diversity differently**, with some embracing and others resisting change. |
|
1397 |
+ |
|
1398 |
+--- |
|
1399 |
+ |
|
1400 |
+## **Findings** |
|
1401 |
+1. **Primary Observations:** |
|
1402 |
+ - The study **challenges traditional integration theories**, arguing that non-migrant groups also undergo adaptation processes. |
|
1403 |
+ - Some residents **struggle with demographic changes**, while others see diversity as an asset. |
|
1404 |
+ |
|
1405 |
+2. **Subgroup Trends:** |
|
1406 |
+ - Young, educated individuals in urban areas **are more open to cultural diversity**. |
|
1407 |
+ - Older and less mobile residents **report feelings of displacement and social isolation**. |
|
1408 |
+ |
|
1409 |
+3. **Specific Case Analysis:** |
|
1410 |
+ - Examines how **people without migration background navigate majority-minority settings** in cities like Amsterdam and Vienna. |
|
1411 |
+ - Analyzes **whether former ethnic majority groups now perceive themselves as minorities**. |
|
1412 |
+ |
|
1413 |
+--- |
|
1414 |
+ |
|
1415 |
+## **Critique and Observations** |
|
1416 |
+1. **Strengths of the Study:** |
|
1417 |
+ - **Innovative approach** by examining the impact of migration on native populations. |
|
1418 |
+ - Uses **both qualitative and quantitative data** for robust analysis. |
|
1419 |
+ |
|
1420 |
+2. **Limitations of the Study:** |
|
1421 |
+ - Limited to **Western European urban settings**, missing perspectives from other global regions. |
|
1422 |
+ - Does not fully explore **policy interventions for fostering social cohesion**. |
|
1423 |
+ |
|
1424 |
+3. **Suggestions for Improvement:** |
|
1425 |
+ - Expand research to **other geographical contexts** to understand migration effects globally. |
|
1426 |
+ - Investigate **long-term trends in urban adaptation and community building**. |
|
1427 |
+ |
|
1428 |
+--- |
|
1429 |
+ |
|
1430 |
+## **Relevance to Subproject** |
|
1431 |
+- Provides a **new perspective on urban integration**, shifting focus from migrants to native-born populations. |
|
1432 |
+- Highlights the **role of social and economic power in shaping urban diversity outcomes**. |
|
1433 |
+- Challenges existing **assimilation theories by showing bidirectional adaptation in diverse cities**. |
|
1434 |
+ |
|
1435 |
+--- |
|
1436 |
+ |
|
1437 |
+## **Suggestions for Further Exploration** |
|
1438 |
+1. Study how **local policies shape attitudes toward urban diversity**. |
|
1439 |
+2. Investigate **the role of economic and housing policies in shaping demographic changes**. |
|
1440 |
+3. Explore **how social networks influence perceptions of migration and diversity**. |
|
1441 |
+ |
|
1442 |
+--- |
|
1443 |
+ |
|
1444 |
+## **Summary of Research Study** |
|
1445 |
+This study examines how **people without migration background experience demographic change in majority-minority cities**. Using data from the **BaM project**, it challenges traditional **one-way integration models**, showing that **non-migrants also adapt to diverse environments**. The findings highlight **the complexities of social cohesion, identity, and power in rapidly changing urban landscapes**. |
|
1446 |
+ |
|
1447 |
+This summary provides an accessible, at-a-glance overview of the study’s contributions. Please refer to the full paper for in-depth analysis. |
|
1448 |
+ |
|
1449 |
+--- |
|
1450 |
+ |
|
1451 |
+## **📄 Download Full Study** |
|
1452 |
+[[Download Full Study>>attach:10.1080_1369183X.2023.2182548.pdf]] |
|
1453 |
+ |
|
1454 |
+{{/expand}} |
|
1455 |
+ |
|
1456 |
+{{html}}<hr style="border: 3px solid red;">{{/html}} |
|
1457 |
+ |
|
1458 |
+{{expand title="Study: Factors Associated with Completion of a Drug Treatment Court Diversion Program" expanded="false"}} |
|
1459 |
+**Source:** *Substance Use & Misuse* |
1208 |
1208 |
**Date of Publication:** *2002* |
1209 |
|
-**Author(s):** *Sarah A. Tishkoff, Scott M. Williams* |
1210 |
|
-**Title:** *"Genetic Analysis of African Populations: Human Evolution and Complex Disease"* |
1211 |
|
-**DOI:** [10.1038/nrg865](https://doi.org/10.1038/nrg865) |
1212 |
|
-**Subject Matter:** *Population Genetics, Human Evolution, Complex Diseases* |
|
1461 |
+**Author(s):** *Clifford A. Butzin, Christine A. Saum, Frank R. Scarpitti* |
|
1462 |
+**Title:** *"Factors Associated with Completion of a Drug Treatment Court Diversion Program"* |
|
1463 |
+**DOI:** [10.1081/JA-120014424](https://doi.org/10.1081/JA-120014424) |
|
1464 |
+**Subject Matter:** *Substance Use, Criminal Justice, Drug Courts* |
1213 |
1213 |
|
1214 |
1214 |
--- |
1215 |
1215 |
|
1216 |
1216 |
## **Key Statistics** |
1217 |
1217 |
1. **General Observations:** |
1218 |
|
- - Africa harbors **the highest genetic diversity** of any region, making it key to understanding human evolution. |
1219 |
|
- - The study analyzes **genetic variation and linkage disequilibrium (LD) in African populations**. |
|
1470 |
+ - Study examined **drug treatment court success rates** among first-time offenders. |
|
1471 |
+ - Strongest predictors of **successful completion were employment status and race**. |
1220 |
1220 |
|
1221 |
1221 |
2. **Subgroup Analysis:** |
1222 |
|
- - African populations exhibit **greater genetic differentiation compared to non-Africans**. |
1223 |
|
- - **Migration and admixture** have shaped modern African genomes over the past **100,000 years**. |
|
1474 |
+ - Individuals with **stable jobs were more likely to complete the program**. |
|
1475 |
+ - **Black participants had lower success rates**, suggesting potential systemic disparities. |
1224 |
1224 |
|
1225 |
1225 |
3. **Other Significant Data Points:** |
1226 |
|
- - The **effective population size (Ne) of Africans** is higher than that of non-African populations. |
1227 |
|
- - LD blocks are **shorter in African genomes**, suggesting more historical recombination events. |
|
1478 |
+ - **Education level was positively correlated** with program completion. |
|
1479 |
+ - Frequency of **drug use before enrollment affected treatment outcomes**. |
1228 |
1228 |
|
1229 |
1229 |
--- |
1230 |
1230 |
|
1231 |
1231 |
## **Findings** |
1232 |
1232 |
1. **Primary Observations:** |
1233 |
|
- - African populations are the **most genetically diverse**, supporting the *Recent African Origin* hypothesis. |
1234 |
|
- - Genetic variation in African populations can **help fine-map complex disease genes**. |
|
1485 |
+ - **Social stability factors** (employment, education) were key to treatment success. |
|
1486 |
+ - **Race and pre-existing substance use patterns** influenced completion rates. |
1235 |
1235 |
|
1236 |
1236 |
2. **Subgroup Trends:** |
1237 |
|
- - **West Africans exhibit higher genetic diversity** than East Africans due to differing migration patterns. |
1238 |
|
- - Populations such as **San hunter-gatherers show deep genetic divergence**. |
|
1489 |
+ - White offenders had **higher completion rates** than Black offenders. |
|
1490 |
+ - Drug court success was **higher for those with lower initial drug use frequency**. |
1239 |
1239 |
|
1240 |
1240 |
3. **Specific Case Analysis:** |
1241 |
|
- - Admixture in African Americans includes **West African and European genetic contributions**. |
1242 |
|
- - SNP (single nucleotide polymorphism) diversity in African genomes **exceeds that of non-African groups**. |
|
1493 |
+ - **Individuals with strong social ties were more likely to finish the program**. |
|
1494 |
+ - Success rates were **significantly higher for participants with case management support**. |
1243 |
1243 |
|
1244 |
1244 |
--- |
1245 |
1245 |
|
1246 |
1246 |
## **Critique and Observations** |
1247 |
1247 |
1. **Strengths of the Study:** |
1248 |
|
- - Provides **comprehensive genetic analysis** of diverse African populations. |
1249 |
|
- - Highlights **how genetic diversity impacts health disparities and disease risks**. |
|
1500 |
+ - **First empirical study on drug court program success factors**. |
|
1501 |
+ - Uses **longitudinal data** for post-treatment analysis. |
1250 |
1250 |
|
1251 |
1251 |
2. **Limitations of the Study:** |
1252 |
|
- - Many **African populations remain understudied**, limiting full understanding of diversity. |
1253 |
|
- - Focuses more on genetic variation than on **specific disease mechanisms**. |
|
1504 |
+ - Lacks **qualitative data on personal motivation and treatment engagement**. |
|
1505 |
+ - Focuses on **short-term program success** without tracking **long-term relapse rates**. |
1254 |
1254 |
|
1255 |
1255 |
3. **Suggestions for Improvement:** |
1256 |
|
- - Expand research into **underrepresented African populations**. |
1257 |
|
- - Integrate **whole-genome sequencing for a more detailed evolutionary timeline**. |
|
1508 |
+ - Future research should examine **racial disparities in drug court outcomes**. |
|
1509 |
+ - Study **how community resources impact long-term recovery**. |
1258 |
1258 |
|
1259 |
1259 |
--- |
1260 |
1260 |
|
1261 |
1261 |
## **Relevance to Subproject** |
1262 |
|
-- Supports **genetic models of human evolution** and the **out-of-Africa hypothesis**. |
1263 |
|
-- Reinforces **Africa’s key role in disease gene mapping and precision medicine**. |
1264 |
|
-- Provides insight into **historical migration patterns and their genetic impact**. |
|
1514 |
+- Provides insight into **what factors contribute to drug court program success**. |
|
1515 |
+- Highlights **racial disparities in criminal justice-based rehabilitation programs**. |
|
1516 |
+- Supports **policy discussions on improving access to drug treatment for marginalized groups**. |
1265 |
1265 |
|
1266 |
1266 |
--- |
1267 |
1267 |
|
1268 |
1268 |
## **Suggestions for Further Exploration** |
1269 |
|
-1. Investigate **genetic adaptations to local environments within Africa**. |
1270 |
|
-2. Study **the role of African genetic diversity in disease resistance**. |
1271 |
|
-3. Expand research on **how ancient migration patterns shaped modern genetic structure**. |
|
1521 |
+1. Investigate **the role of mental health in drug court success rates**. |
|
1522 |
+2. Assess **long-term relapse prevention strategies post-treatment**. |
|
1523 |
+3. Explore **alternative diversion programs beyond traditional drug courts**. |
1272 |
1272 |
|
1273 |
1273 |
--- |
1274 |
1274 |
|
1275 |
1275 |
## **Summary of Research Study** |
1276 |
|
-This study explores the **genetic diversity of African populations**, analyzing their role in **human evolution and complex disease research**. The findings highlight **Africa’s unique genetic landscape**, confirming it as the most genetically diverse continent. The research provides valuable insights into **how genetic variation influences disease susceptibility, evolution, and population structure**. |
|
1528 |
+This study examines **factors influencing the completion of drug treatment court programs**, identifying **employment, education, and race as key predictors**. The research underscores **systemic disparities in drug court outcomes**, emphasizing the need for **improved support systems for at-risk populations**. |
1277 |
1277 |
|
1278 |
1278 |
This summary provides an accessible, at-a-glance overview of the study’s contributions. Please refer to the full paper for in-depth analysis. |
1279 |
1279 |
|
... |
... |
@@ -1280,7 +1280,7 @@ |
1280 |
1280 |
--- |
1281 |
1281 |
|
1282 |
1282 |
## **📄 Download Full Study** |
1283 |
|
-[[Download Full Study>>attach:10.1038_nrg865MODERN.pdf]] |
|
1535 |
+[[Download Full Study>>attach:10.1081_JA-120014424.pdf]] |
1284 |
1284 |
|
1285 |
1285 |
{{/expand}} |
1286 |
1286 |
|
... |
... |
@@ -1287,4 +1287,252 @@ |
1287 |
1287 |
{{html}}<hr style="border: 3px solid red;">{{/html}} |
1288 |
1288 |
|
1289 |
1289 |
|
|
1542 |
+{{expand title="Study: Cross-Cultural Sources of Measurement Error in Substance Use Surveys" expanded="false"}} |
|
1543 |
+**Source:** *Substance Use & Misuse* |
|
1544 |
+**Date of Publication:** *2003* |
|
1545 |
+**Author(s):** *Timothy P. Johnson, Phillip J. Bowman* |
|
1546 |
+**Title:** *"Cross-Cultural Sources of Measurement Error in Substance Use Surveys"* |
|
1547 |
+**DOI:** [10.1081/JA-120023394](https://doi.org/10.1081/JA-120023394) |
|
1548 |
+**Subject Matter:** *Survey Methodology, Racial Disparities, Substance Use Research* |
1290 |
1290 |
|
|
1550 |
+--- |
|
1551 |
+ |
|
1552 |
+## **Key Statistics** |
|
1553 |
+1. **General Observations:** |
|
1554 |
+ - Study examined **how racial and cultural factors influence self-reported substance use data**. |
|
1555 |
+ - Analyzed **36 empirical studies from 1977–2003** on survey reliability across racial/ethnic groups. |
|
1556 |
+ |
|
1557 |
+2. **Subgroup Analysis:** |
|
1558 |
+ - Black and Latino respondents **were more likely to underreport drug use** compared to White respondents. |
|
1559 |
+ - **Cultural stigma and distrust in research institutions** affected self-report accuracy. |
|
1560 |
+ |
|
1561 |
+3. **Other Significant Data Points:** |
|
1562 |
+ - **Surveys using biological validation (urinalysis, hair tests) revealed underreporting trends**. |
|
1563 |
+ - **Higher recantation rates** (denying past drug use) were observed among minority respondents. |
|
1564 |
+ |
|
1565 |
+--- |
|
1566 |
+ |
|
1567 |
+## **Findings** |
|
1568 |
+1. **Primary Observations:** |
|
1569 |
+ - Racial/ethnic disparities in **substance use reporting bias survey-based research**. |
|
1570 |
+ - **Social desirability and cultural norms impact data reliability**. |
|
1571 |
+ |
|
1572 |
+2. **Subgroup Trends:** |
|
1573 |
+ - White respondents were **more likely to overreport** substance use. |
|
1574 |
+ - Black and Latino respondents **had higher recantation rates**, particularly in face-to-face interviews. |
|
1575 |
+ |
|
1576 |
+3. **Specific Case Analysis:** |
|
1577 |
+ - Mode of survey administration **significantly influenced reporting accuracy**. |
|
1578 |
+ - **Self-administered surveys produced more reliable data than interviewer-administered surveys**. |
|
1579 |
+ |
|
1580 |
+--- |
|
1581 |
+ |
|
1582 |
+## **Critique and Observations** |
|
1583 |
+1. **Strengths of the Study:** |
|
1584 |
+ - **Comprehensive review of 36 studies** on measurement error in substance use reporting. |
|
1585 |
+ - Identifies **systemic biases affecting racial/ethnic survey reliability**. |
|
1586 |
+ |
|
1587 |
+2. **Limitations of the Study:** |
|
1588 |
+ - Relies on **secondary data analysis**, limiting direct experimental control. |
|
1589 |
+ - Does not explore **how measurement error impacts policy decisions**. |
|
1590 |
+ |
|
1591 |
+3. **Suggestions for Improvement:** |
|
1592 |
+ - Future research should **incorporate mixed-method approaches** (qualitative & quantitative). |
|
1593 |
+ - Investigate **how survey design can reduce racial reporting disparities**. |
|
1594 |
+ |
|
1595 |
+--- |
|
1596 |
+ |
|
1597 |
+## **Relevance to Subproject** |
|
1598 |
+- Supports research on **racial disparities in self-reported health behaviors**. |
|
1599 |
+- Highlights **survey methodology issues that impact substance use epidemiology**. |
|
1600 |
+- Provides insights for **improving data accuracy in public health research**. |
|
1601 |
+ |
|
1602 |
+--- |
|
1603 |
+ |
|
1604 |
+## **Suggestions for Further Exploration** |
|
1605 |
+1. Investigate **how survey design impacts racial disparities in self-reported health data**. |
|
1606 |
+2. Study **alternative data collection methods (biometric validation, passive data tracking)**. |
|
1607 |
+3. Explore **the role of social stigma in self-reported health behaviors**. |
|
1608 |
+ |
|
1609 |
+--- |
|
1610 |
+ |
|
1611 |
+## **Summary of Research Study** |
|
1612 |
+This study examines **cross-cultural biases in self-reported substance use surveys**, showing that **racial/ethnic minorities are more likely to underreport drug use** due to **social stigma, research distrust, and survey administration methods**. The findings highlight **critical issues in public health data collection and the need for improved survey design**. |
|
1613 |
+ |
|
1614 |
+This summary provides an accessible, at-a-glance overview of the study’s contributions. Please refer to the full paper for in-depth analysis. |
|
1615 |
+ |
|
1616 |
+--- |
|
1617 |
+ |
|
1618 |
+## **📄 Download Full Study** |
|
1619 |
+[[Download Full Study>>attach:10.1081_JA-120023394.pdf]] |
|
1620 |
+ |
|
1621 |
+{{/expand}} |
|
1622 |
+ |
|
1623 |
+{{html}}<hr style="border: 3px solid red;">{{/html}} |
|
1624 |
+ |
|
1625 |
+{{expand title="Study: Cross-Cultural Sources of Measurement Error in Substance Use Surveys" expanded="false"}} |
|
1626 |
+**Source:** *Substance Use & Misuse* |
|
1627 |
+**Date of Publication:** *2003* |
|
1628 |
+**Author(s):** *Timothy P. Johnson, Phillip J. Bowman* |
|
1629 |
+**Title:** *"Cross-Cultural Sources of Measurement Error in Substance Use Surveys"* |
|
1630 |
+**DOI:** [10.1081/JA-120023394](https://doi.org/10.1081/JA-120023394) |
|
1631 |
+**Subject Matter:** *Survey Methodology, Racial Disparities, Substance Use Research* |
|
1632 |
+ |
|
1633 |
+--- |
|
1634 |
+ |
|
1635 |
+## **Key Statistics** |
|
1636 |
+1. **General Observations:** |
|
1637 |
+ - Study examined **how racial and cultural factors influence self-reported substance use data**. |
|
1638 |
+ - Analyzed **36 empirical studies from 1977–2003** on survey reliability across racial/ethnic groups. |
|
1639 |
+ |
|
1640 |
+2. **Subgroup Analysis:** |
|
1641 |
+ - Black and Latino respondents **were more likely to underreport drug use** compared to White respondents. |
|
1642 |
+ - **Cultural stigma and distrust in research institutions** affected self-report accuracy. |
|
1643 |
+ |
|
1644 |
+3. **Other Significant Data Points:** |
|
1645 |
+ - **Surveys using biological validation (urinalysis, hair tests) revealed underreporting trends**. |
|
1646 |
+ - **Higher recantation rates** (denying past drug use) were observed among minority respondents. |
|
1647 |
+ |
|
1648 |
+--- |
|
1649 |
+ |
|
1650 |
+## **Findings** |
|
1651 |
+1. **Primary Observations:** |
|
1652 |
+ - Racial/ethnic disparities in **substance use reporting bias survey-based research**. |
|
1653 |
+ - **Social desirability and cultural norms impact data reliability**. |
|
1654 |
+ |
|
1655 |
+2. **Subgroup Trends:** |
|
1656 |
+ - White respondents were **more likely to overreport** substance use. |
|
1657 |
+ - Black and Latino respondents **had higher recantation rates**, particularly in face-to-face interviews. |
|
1658 |
+ |
|
1659 |
+3. **Specific Case Analysis:** |
|
1660 |
+ - Mode of survey administration **significantly influenced reporting accuracy**. |
|
1661 |
+ - **Self-administered surveys produced more reliable data than interviewer-administered surveys**. |
|
1662 |
+ |
|
1663 |
+--- |
|
1664 |
+ |
|
1665 |
+## **Critique and Observations** |
|
1666 |
+1. **Strengths of the Study:** |
|
1667 |
+ - **Comprehensive review of 36 studies** on measurement error in substance use reporting. |
|
1668 |
+ - Identifies **systemic biases affecting racial/ethnic survey reliability**. |
|
1669 |
+ |
|
1670 |
+2. **Limitations of the Study:** |
|
1671 |
+ - Relies on **secondary data analysis**, limiting direct experimental control. |
|
1672 |
+ - Does not explore **how measurement error impacts policy decisions**. |
|
1673 |
+ |
|
1674 |
+3. **Suggestions for Improvement:** |
|
1675 |
+ - Future research should **incorporate mixed-method approaches** (qualitative & quantitative). |
|
1676 |
+ - Investigate **how survey design can reduce racial reporting disparities**. |
|
1677 |
+ |
|
1678 |
+--- |
|
1679 |
+ |
|
1680 |
+## **Relevance to Subproject** |
|
1681 |
+- Supports research on **racial disparities in self-reported health behaviors**. |
|
1682 |
+- Highlights **survey methodology issues that impact substance use epidemiology**. |
|
1683 |
+- Provides insights for **improving data accuracy in public health research**. |
|
1684 |
+ |
|
1685 |
+--- |
|
1686 |
+ |
|
1687 |
+## **Suggestions for Further Exploration** |
|
1688 |
+1. Investigate **how survey design impacts racial disparities in self-reported health data**. |
|
1689 |
+2. Study **alternative data collection methods (biometric validation, passive data tracking)**. |
|
1690 |
+3. Explore **the role of social stigma in self-reported health behaviors**. |
|
1691 |
+ |
|
1692 |
+--- |
|
1693 |
+ |
|
1694 |
+## **Summary of Research Study** |
|
1695 |
+This study examines **cross-cultural biases in self-reported substance use surveys**, showing that **racial/ethnic minorities are more likely to underreport drug use** due to **social stigma, research distrust, and survey administration methods**. The findings highlight **critical issues in public health data collection and the need for improved survey design**. |
|
1696 |
+ |
|
1697 |
+This summary provides an accessible, at-a-glance overview of the study’s contributions. Please refer to the full paper for in-depth analysis. |
|
1698 |
+ |
|
1699 |
+--- |
|
1700 |
+ |
|
1701 |
+## **📄 Download Full Study** |
|
1702 |
+[[Download Full Study>>attach:10.1081_JA-120023394.pdf]] |
|
1703 |
+ |
|
1704 |
+{{/expand}} |
|
1705 |
+ |
|
1706 |
+{{html}}<hr style="border: 3px solid red;">{{/html}} |
|
1707 |
+ |
|
1708 |
+{{expand title="Study: Factors Associated with Completion of a Drug Treatment Court Diversion Program" expanded="false"}} |
|
1709 |
+**Source:** *Substance Use & Misuse* |
|
1710 |
+**Date of Publication:** *2002* |
|
1711 |
+**Author(s):** *Clifford A. Butzin, Christine A. Saum, Frank R. Scarpitti* |
|
1712 |
+**Title:** *"Factors Associated with Completion of a Drug Treatment Court Diversion Program"* |
|
1713 |
+**DOI:** [10.1081/JA-120014424](https://doi.org/10.1081/JA-120014424) |
|
1714 |
+**Subject Matter:** *Substance Use, Criminal Justice, Drug Courts* |
|
1715 |
+ |
|
1716 |
+--- |
|
1717 |
+ |
|
1718 |
+## **Key Statistics** |
|
1719 |
+1. **General Observations:** |
|
1720 |
+ - Study examined **drug treatment court success rates** among first-time offenders. |
|
1721 |
+ - Strongest predictors of **successful completion were employment status and race**. |
|
1722 |
+ |
|
1723 |
+2. **Subgroup Analysis:** |
|
1724 |
+ - Individuals with **stable jobs were more likely to complete the program**. |
|
1725 |
+ - **Black participants had lower success rates**, suggesting potential systemic disparities. |
|
1726 |
+ |
|
1727 |
+3. **Other Significant Data Points:** |
|
1728 |
+ - **Education level was positively correlated** with program completion. |
|
1729 |
+ - Frequency of **drug use before enrollment affected treatment outcomes**. |
|
1730 |
+ |
|
1731 |
+--- |
|
1732 |
+ |
|
1733 |
+## **Findings** |
|
1734 |
+1. **Primary Observations:** |
|
1735 |
+ - **Social stability factors** (employment, education) were key to treatment success. |
|
1736 |
+ - **Race and pre-existing substance use patterns** influenced completion rates. |
|
1737 |
+ |
|
1738 |
+2. **Subgroup Trends:** |
|
1739 |
+ - White offenders had **higher completion rates** than Black offenders. |
|
1740 |
+ - Drug court success was **higher for those with lower initial drug use frequency**. |
|
1741 |
+ |
|
1742 |
+3. **Specific Case Analysis:** |
|
1743 |
+ - **Individuals with strong social ties were more likely to finish the program**. |
|
1744 |
+ - Success rates were **significantly higher for participants with case management support**. |
|
1745 |
+ |
|
1746 |
+--- |
|
1747 |
+ |
|
1748 |
+## **Critique and Observations** |
|
1749 |
+1. **Strengths of the Study:** |
|
1750 |
+ - **First empirical study on drug court program success factors**. |
|
1751 |
+ - Uses **longitudinal data** for post-treatment analysis. |
|
1752 |
+ |
|
1753 |
+2. **Limitations of the Study:** |
|
1754 |
+ - Lacks **qualitative data on personal motivation and treatment engagement**. |
|
1755 |
+ - Focuses on **short-term program success** without tracking **long-term relapse rates**. |
|
1756 |
+ |
|
1757 |
+3. **Suggestions for Improvement:** |
|
1758 |
+ - Future research should examine **racial disparities in drug court outcomes**. |
|
1759 |
+ - Study **how community resources impact long-term recovery**. |
|
1760 |
+ |
|
1761 |
+--- |
|
1762 |
+ |
|
1763 |
+## **Relevance to Subproject** |
|
1764 |
+- Provides insight into **what factors contribute to drug court program success**. |
|
1765 |
+- Highlights **racial disparities in criminal justice-based rehabilitation programs**. |
|
1766 |
+- Supports **policy discussions on improving access to drug treatment for marginalized groups**. |
|
1767 |
+ |
|
1768 |
+--- |
|
1769 |
+ |
|
1770 |
+## **Suggestions for Further Exploration** |
|
1771 |
+1. Investigate **the role of mental health in drug court success rates**. |
|
1772 |
+2. Assess **long-term relapse prevention strategies post-treatment**. |
|
1773 |
+3. Explore **alternative diversion programs beyond traditional drug courts**. |
|
1774 |
+ |
|
1775 |
+--- |
|
1776 |
+ |
|
1777 |
+## **Summary of Research Study** |
|
1778 |
+This study examines **factors influencing the completion of drug treatment court programs**, identifying **employment, education, and race as key predictors**. The research underscores **systemic disparities in drug court outcomes**, emphasizing the need for **improved support systems for at-risk populations**. |
|
1779 |
+ |
|
1780 |
+This summary provides an accessible, at-a-glance overview of the study’s contributions. Please refer to the full paper for in-depth analysis. |
|
1781 |
+ |
|
1782 |
+--- |
|
1783 |
+ |
|
1784 |
+## **📄 Download Full Study** |
|
1785 |
+[[Download Full Study>>attach:10.1081_JA-120014424.pdf]] |
|
1786 |
+ |
|
1787 |
+{{/expand}} |
|
1788 |
+ |
|
1789 |
+{{html}}<hr style="border: 3px solid red;">{{/html}} |
|
1790 |
+ |